Dangling Pointers and References

Learn about an important consideration when returning pointers and references from functions
This lesson is part of the course:

Intro to C++ Programming

Become a software engineer with C++. Starting from the basics, we guide you step by step along the way

Free, Unlimited Access
Abstract art representing computer programming
Ryan McCombe
Ryan McCombe
Updated

Now that we’re working with pointers and references, we need to talk briefly about memory management.

This is a large topic - we have a full chapter dedicated to it in the next course. For now, we just need to understand an important consideration when we’re using references or pointers to objects created in our function.

Let's demonstrate the problem with a simple program:

#include <iostream>
using namespace std;

int* GetNumber(){
  int Number{1};
  return &Number;
}

int main(){
  int* Result{GetNumber()};
  cout << "Result: " << *Result;
}

We might expect this to log out 1, but that is not the case:

Result: -858993460

The compiler should give us a warning that we might have been doing something wrong on our return statement:

Address of stack memory associated with local variable Number returned

Let's delve a little deeper into this warning, as we should understand what’s going on here.

Stack Memory

In the introductory lessons, we covered the idea of the stack, and how our functions each create stack frames.

Stack frames are a form of memory management.

The parameters and local variables that our functions create are stored within these stack frames.

Within our call to GetNumber(), we are allocated memory to store the int we created. We then returned that memory address to our main function:

Diagram showing the return of a pointer from a function

However, stack frames are an automated form of memory management. When the function ends, its stack frame, and all the objects stored within it are destroyed.

We can see this by using a custom type with a destructor:

#include <iostream>
using namespace std;

struct SomeType {
  int Value{1};
  ~SomeType(){ cout << "Destroying\n"; }
};

SomeType* GetObject(){
  SomeType SomeObject;
  return &SomeObject;
}

int main(){
  SomeType* Result{GetObject()};
  cout << "Result: " << Result->Value;
}
Destroying
Result: -858993460

Dangling Pointers and References

When we have a pointer or reference to an object, and that object is then deleted, the pointer is no longer useful. It is sometimes referred to as a dangling pointer or dangling reference.

If we attempt to use a dangling pointer or reference, our program's behavior becomes undefined. This often leads to unpredictable results, and may cause crashes or other serious issues.

This is because the memory our object was using is freed up for other purposes, meaning we no longer know what will be stored there by the time we use our pointer or reference.

Diagram showing a dangling pointer

Why this only applies to references and pointers

Previously, we've been creating and returning local variables by value without issues. When we return a value from a function, that value is typically copied or moved to the calling function's stack frame or another appropriate location.

When the thing we returned was the value, everything worked as expected.

However, when a pointer (or reference) is returned, that pointer can refer to a memory location that is about to be freed. When that pointer is then used, unpredictable things can happen, as the first example demonstrated.

Storage Durations

In C++, objects have different lifetimes depending on how they're created. This concept is known as storage duration. The local variables we've been using in functions have what's called automatic storage duration - they're automatically created when the function is called and destroyed when it ends.

However, there are other storage durations in C++:

  1. Static storage duration: Objects exist for the entire run of the program.
  2. Thread storage duration: Each thread has its own copy of the object.
  3. Dynamic storage duration: The programmer controls when objects are created and destroyed.

For now, we're primarily concerned with automatic storage duration and its implications. When we need an object to last longer than a single function call, we have several options:

  • Create it in the global scope (though this should be used sparingly)
  • Create it inside the main function
  • Make it part of a longer-lived object

In the next course, we'll delve deeper into memory management and explore how to control object lifetimes more precisely. This will include techniques for dynamic allocation and smart pointers, which give us more flexibility in managing object lifetimes.

Summary

In this lesson, we briefly introduced the concept of storage durations, and how memory allocated on the stack is automatically freed when the stack frame is destroyed.

In particular, we covered the implications this has for objects returned by pointer or reference from functions, and how improper usage can cause memory problems.

Next Chapter: Polymorphism

In the next chapter, we introduce polymorphism - a key technique that lets us ramp up the complexity of our program, without necessarily making our code more complex. We’ll cover:

  • Introduction to Polymorphism: Defining polymorphism in the context of C++ programming and its importance in creating flexible, reusable code.
  • Types of Polymorphism: Discussing the different types, such as compile-time (overloading) and runtime polymorphism (virtual functions).
  • Function Overloading: Covering how functions can be overloaded to implement different behaviors depending on the data type they are called with.
  • Virtual Functions and Inheritance: Exploring how virtual functions enable runtime polymorphism through inheritance hierarchies.
  • Best Practices and Common Pitfalls: Highlighting best practices in implementing polymorphism and common mistakes to avoid.
  • Case Studies and Examples: Including real-world examples and case studies to demonstrate the use of polymorphism in various scenarios.

Was this lesson useful?

Next Lesson

Function Overloading

This lesson provides an in-depth look at function overloading in C++, covering its importance, implementation, and best practices
3D art showing a character using a compass
Ryan McCombe
Ryan McCombe
Updated
Lesson Contents

Dangling Pointers and References

Learn about an important consideration when returning pointers and references from functions

3D art showing a progammer setting up a development environment
This lesson is part of the course:

Intro to C++ Programming

Become a software engineer with C++. Starting from the basics, we guide you step by step along the way

Free, Unlimited Access
Memory, References and Pointers
3D art showing a progammer setting up a development environment
This lesson is part of the course:

Intro to C++ Programming

Become a software engineer with C++. Starting from the basics, we guide you step by step along the way

Free, unlimited access

This course includes:

  • 60 Lessons
  • Over 200 Quiz Questions
  • 95% Positive Reviews
  • Regularly Updated
  • Help and FAQ
Next Lesson

Function Overloading

This lesson provides an in-depth look at function overloading in C++, covering its importance, implementation, and best practices
3D art showing a character using a compass
Contact|Privacy Policy|Terms of Use
Copyright © 2024 - All Rights Reserved